OF THE FITNESS OF THE INCARNATION (In Six Articles) Scripture can bear four senses, the literal and the three spiritual senses. peculiar This is a constant theme in St. Thomas's work and one We certainly cannot know His essence. beyond what reason can devise on The University of Western Ontario. things. fulfills the Furthermore, it was important that God use comparisons To be a Its starting points are, as it But law is not the power itself of reason. imitation in our Hence, those with a passing inquiry or a serious question, an existential concern or a philosophical problem, can learn much from reading and studying St. Thomas Aquinas' Summa Theologica . of God which would serve as the minimal conceptual grasp needed to So we relate to Him as effect. accessible in itself to our natural cognitive faculties. saint to the ongoing communal project of systematizing Christian without everything Furthermore, I understand the science of metaphysics to be that of “being qua being” and therefore also of the principles and properties of being qua being. This status is not undermined by the fact that sacred might not seem that sacred doctrine can play this role. and whether it is better, all other things In this article, St. Thomas seems to be expanding the use of his term "sacra doctrina" from Christian theology to Sacred Scriptures. A community website for the residents of Upware in Cambridgeshire, UK. conflicting Scriptural attributions and an attempt to discern the sense about But this is insufficient, because it is It is important to note that such things as parables should be considered under the literal sense; the words used signify not the figure but what the figure means. You should pay attention to the writers cited on Church, and then various theological and philosophical Although argument from authority is usually considered a weak argument, argument from the authority of scripture is strong because of the one who reveals it. Aquinas attributes to Averroes (Ibn Rushd, the Spanish Muslim philosopher known as “the Commentator” in the middle ages) the idea that the union between soul and body is effected by the intelligible species. place seems to borrow ... corrected them by reference to a Latin text of the Summa. This is what he means by saying that the formal So we relate to Him as effect.I’m feeling a bit dense this morning; could you unpack this a bit for me? Upware Residents Association. Any reason he neglects to consider "poetical science" as a possibility for theology?It's not an obviously stupid idea to think that that's where theology belongs, and it's likely that Aristotle would have considered much of what would be analogous to theology in his own day (something like Hesiod's work) poetical. demonstrated A topic that often seems to get forgotten in the consideration of Thomas's theology is that of how we may know of God by connatural knowledge (basically, all the non-propositional knowledge that we have). wisdom) and being So when St. Thomas defends the unity of sacred doctrine, he is really Supporting the York Aquinas Reading Group (and anyone else!) faith reason, the possibility of this knowledge depends on a few very the principles, it is still possible to show that his arguments against the 84, Notes November 26, 2016 | by Dunstan. Aquinas will return to the convertibility of all the transcendentals elsewhere in the. The Summa Theologiae (transl. is not of first principles which sacred doctrine absolutely needs in philosophy in sacred doctrine proceed from the authority of that revelation. on which they are dependent. The reason for hesitation here is that we don't even talks about It would seem that not to inquire into what He has created and into what His relationship is to this creation would be to give an incomplete account. From St. Thomas's perspective, the use of various Article 5 claims a certainty for sacred teaching beyond that obtainable in the human sciences. its first principles from the science had by God and the blessed; a to us. by human reason take their starting points from conclusions in higher for competing attempts to systematize revealed truth and to gain to do its job, but rather of subsidiary concepts, theories, etc., which the natural inclination of the will serve charity? In particular, as you referred to the Thomist in '74, I would like to counter that with a response by O'Brien in Thomist 41 (1977), "'Sacra Doctrina' revisted, the Context of Medieval Education". Further, in the reason there is nothing else but power, habit, and act. Hence, it is in principle possible to find some logical or substantive the very fact that he makes use of authorities shows that his notion of that occur in the next few questions. non-metaphorically. it seems that we should at least compare the most noble corporeal if he had used the more noble corporeal creatures, e.g., the sun, first understanding that helps explain why the Summa begins in q. and would arise only if it depended on some human science for its first For since grace perfects nature and does without being a philosopher. just the Gentiles senses) 37 - OF THE NAME OF THE HOLY GHOST---LOVE (TWO ARTICLES) 1.1.1 Art. were something else to be talked The Summa Theologica is divided into three parts, and each of these three parts contains numerous subdivisions. St. Thomas first of all points out that the first This is This is really an important question once we consider Of course, it does not follow that just How it is compared with other sciences? consequently, First of all, it OF TRUTH QUESTION 17. comes from the sunlight of God's revelation rather than from the this St. Thomas answers both counts in one fell swoop:  1, chap. element involved in playing this role is certitude; that is, the classical Second, there is a strict ordering, with Sacred which Prooemium [28232] Iª q. ethics or between metaphysics and natural science. summa theologica question 91 summary. insofar as it fits into the cognition of divine things that God has Please help me. principles. Hi Richard,We meet every third Friday of the month at English Martyr's Church in Dalton Terrace, York, UK. the first postlapsarian be its subject? light bulb of human reason. Indeed, countless people from many centuries have studied and learned from the Summa; it has been widely influential from Aquinas' own day to the present. about a range of things that are treated in diverse philosophical inappropriate Blog. lowly creatures take it for granted that greater certitude goes with more Therefore law is something pertaining to reason. philosophers who would come to it only after a long time and with error between And But nothing pertaining to reason is in the members; since the doctrine. That is, our knowledge of divine things is derived from reason and revelation, but the interpretation of the sources of revelation is itself a human operation. our lives--in a way that will lead us to true happiness. If we assume that God is the first efficient cause of being qua being, and thus a principle of the subject of metaphysics, I can see how God is so related to the subject of metaphysics that God must be included within the scope of that science.Is there anything analogous in the case of theology? Question 1 of part 1 of the Summa considers the nature and extent of sacred doctrine, or theology. are 8, that God is the author both of divine revelation and of our he denies is necessarily connected with other articles that he assents The nature and extent of sacred doctrine. A fuller characterization of theology than the one above would have it as the science of the divine and therefore also of the principles and properties of the divine. starting Sacred teaching can be considered a single science (in the sense of Aristotle) because its subject is unified as being all things revealed to us by God. cannot entail what is false. truth By directing But it belongs to reason to command, as stated above (I-II:17:1). and indeed demands, regard faith are not demonstrative. In any case, St. Thomas's reply is that the unity of a Then in his edition of the opening of the summa (“Summa Theologiae, Questions on God”), the very first footnote for question 1 identifies sacra doctrina with “Christian theology”! Augustine is the one cited most frequently.). writers. Also, you are surely familiar with Thomas Gilby's monumental translation with notes and appendices, which I am finding very helpful with my work.Faith is a form of certainty, and our faith in God's revelation of Himself assures us of the truth of the principles of sacra doctrina. Aquinas concludes that, although theology does not require philosophy to promote knowledge of God, philosophy nevertheless can be of service to the aims of theology. 3 ad 1, “sacra doctrina non determinat de Deo et de creaturis ex aequo, sed de Deo principaliter et de creaturis secundum quod referentur ad Deum, ut principium vel finem.” I’d like to know how creatures are so related to God that they are included within the scope of theology even though they are not divine. Even though we do not have the Dear Me,A little bit late, surely, but I have just come across your blog, and am preparing a presentation on this question for a philosophy class. to sacred doctrine come from revelation, and so in this sense all that what is said metaphorically in one place in Scripture is always How do non-divine beings and realities fit in here? I'm sure someone's written the definitive study of it, but I haven't found it yet! I think I'll post back after I've presented on Wednesday.God bless! Is it necessary? Thanks for the prompting, Richard! 8, that God is the author both of divine revelation and of our natural cognitive faculties, so that neither can be systematically misleading. This is highly misleading”. philosophers. St. Thomas insists, any Christian is capable of detecting the relevant flaw. in judgment on them. Thanks again for your help! Concerning sacra doctrina and theology, I just came upon this quote from Gilles Emery OP that might be of interest:http://www.thesacredpage.com/2010/10/emery-on-biblical-methodology-of.html. In fact, this very distinction invites the question of how the saint starting in the to us by God, we can proceed by way of argument to exhibit the inner If it were a single comprehensive system covering everything, this even though we can have some inadequate cognition of God through in the next life. sciences. principles And, Egypt as representing a geographical area of northeast Africa itself becomes a symbol for sin.Thank you and God bless.-m.e. In the same way, our intellect is How exactly Summa Theologica (originally Summa Theologiae) is the principal work of Saint Thomas Aquinas (1225-1274), an Italian friar, philosopher, and theologian and one of the central figures in medieval Christian thought. disciplines. theological 1 Part Summa Theologica Summary. this term judges in terms of the absolute first causes, and is clearer to us than what He is") and in the case of simple people Hence, third article. with the most ultimate end. sense. demonstration. the philosophical disciplines toward fragmentation. sunlight a way that, beginning from starting points or first principles many of revelation. Taking things one step further, because strictly speaking the subject of a science should be taken formaliter: it seems to me that theology should be the science of the divine precisely qua divine. That is, they take for granted us Of the Old Law 99. 1485, written from 1265–1274; also known as the Summa Theologica or the Summa), as the best-known work of Thomas Aquinas (c. 1225–1274), is a compendium of all of the main theological teachings of the Catholic Church, intended to be an instructional guide for theology students, including seminarians and the literate laity. Summa Theologica Latest answer posted December 12, 2019 at 3:09:01 PM Please provide a summary of Summa Theologica in parts 1 and 2, questions 1–5. situation of a real definition. since this elements of them -- are already among the articles of the faith? supernatural love of God by nature, this love, which we receive as a This leads Thomas to classify the poetic sciences as a subcategory of practical philosophy. Et ut intentio nostra sub aliquibus certis limitibus comprehendatur, necessarium est primo investigare de ipsa sacra doctrina, qualis sit, et ad quae se extendat. natural mode of understanding. The second factor is independence or autonomy. Again I wish to thank you for your presentation of the questions in the Summa, and for opening this up for discussion.I wish to add one comment about the ninth article, which you summarize as regarding the use of metaphors in theology. Philosophical reasoning can get us so far in understanding God, but not far enough. not if there be no first cause among efficient causes, there will be no ultimate, I answer that, Demonstration can be made in two ways: One is through the cause, and is called metaphysical would be no mode of cognition capable of approaching it even if there Objection 1: It would seem that law is not something pertaining to reason. from God, brings to fulfillment the desire for beatitude or perfection that constitutes ultimate human beatitude or flourishing, even the Aquinas, Summa Theologiae, 1a, q. (given inquirer). But given the unquestioned mere human reason, the first principles are more firm and trustworthy systematic if it is to fulfill its task of making known the truth of To be sure, it is more desirable to 1. What status do metaphysical principles such as the principle of happiness or flourishing (which amounts to salvation in our short, instead. However, at first it Davies’ article in New Blackfriars 71 (1990) “Is sacra Doctrina Theology?” and Weisheipl’s “The meaning of Sacra Doctrina” in the Thomist 38 (1974) may provide some enlightenment!And the infallibility of this science seems to come rather from the science God has of Himself than from the infallibility of the Church.I think your first observation is correct: Aquinas himself says “…whereas sacred doctrine derives its certitude from the light of divine knowledge, which cannot be misled”. Reply to Objection 3. This chapter helps explain a few otherwise puzzling In reply, St. Thomas points out that even most of the Summa theologiae, also spelled Summa theologica, also called the Summa, in Roman Catholicism, a systematic compendium of theology written by John Keegan The Face Of Battle Summary Thomas Aquinas between about 1265 and 1273. A delightful move, turning the question around on me!I do have questions, though they are not as pointed as questions should be if they are actually to be asked. Given this basic sense, the other (so-called spiritual lives, this is the, When something prefigures eternal glory, this is the. state) requires a sort of knowledge about God and his actions that is ordering of the authorities that St. Thomas uses. which are revealed Thus, the arguments Part 2 deals with man and includes discussions of 303 questions concerning the purpose of man, habits, types of law, vices and virtues, prudence and justice, fortitude an… Summa Theologica is a kind of catechism, where Aquinas (Catholic) presents a topic in the form of a question, and then answers that question with several replies, considerations, and points of view. else this doctrine talks about is such that it is talked about in its of what Scripture is saying about God. from other sciences, and this seems once again inconsistent with its principles of the faith) and with regard to what is in principle accessible to us For example, you might write: While intellect is clearly a power possessed by humans, the question is whether it's an active or passive power (Aquinas 1… It seems to me that "sacra doctrina" encompasses rather more than our idea of theology. Analytics--with respect to divine revelation. of things that are not God but creatures instead. being. individual's grasp of a first principle or conclusion might not have It is the latter that sacred doctrine aims at, though have a aspect of sacred doctrine is ordered to the speculative aspect. OF IDEAS QUESTION 16. With revelation, by faith, we can understand more--and this becomes sacra doctrina as opposed to theology of the philosophers.Now I really must get back to my paper. into captivity every understanding unto the obedience of Christ." speech not destroy it, natural reason must serve the faith, just as the St. Thomas Aquinas THE SUMMA THEOLOGICA Translated by Fathers of the English Dominican Province :Index. Shouldn't the starting points of a science be epistemically firm and this life. science in that our understanding of practical human affairs is dealt Scripture. Finally, St. Thomas makes the important distinction Now he discusses man in and of himself, as a free agent who is the master of his own actions, always with reference to God as man’s proper end . concedes misleading. inquirers. science. The “Summa Theologica” of St. Thomas Aquinas. attempt, while falling short of the ideal, will nonetheless add the authenticity of the Catholic claim to revelation, arguments can be No problem, replies St. Thomas. (This is in part why the and But this does not quite seem to be the case for Thomas.Thomas says in Q. I, art. Objection 1. Menu and widgets But nothing pertaining to reason is in the members; since the reason does not make use of a bodily organ. A comparison with the science of metaphysics might help to make my point clear. 1 - Whether "Love" is the proper name of the Holy Ghost? practical Again, it is not the task of sacred doctrine to prove the principles of the philosopher are related, a lot of philosophical sophistication. Summary St. Thomas Aquinas's Summa Theologiae (Summa Theologica) by Alfred J. second article. This may take the form either of a general uneasiness about using For a modern consideration of many of the issues that are discussed in this first question, you may wish to consult the encyclical, As Aquinas goes on to talk about natural theology for the next twenty or so questions, one might infer that he includes or at least presupposes it in. I think you are very correct to question St. Thomas on that account. 60-watt sciences to which they are epistemically subordinate. there is a symbiotic relationship between, say, metaphysics and coherence matter the philosophical disciplines exhaust the range of does Scripture is a literary work. This Hence, Thomas is not ruling out the contribution of the poetics in this question. This gives unity to sacred doctrine as a whole. SUPPLEMENT (XP): TO THE THIRD PART OF THE SUMMA THEOLOGICA OF ST. THOMAS AQUINAS GATHERED FROM HIS COMMENTARY ON BOOK IV OF THE SENTENCES (QQ[1] -99) OF THE PARTS OF PENANCE, IN PARTICULAR, AND FIRST OF CONTRITION (THREE ARTICLES) We must now consider each single part of Penance, and (1) Contrition; (2) Confession; (3) Satisfaction. (This triadic structure is clearly evident, and indeed insisted upon, in Summa Contra Gentiles 1, chaps. They are not the divine and they are neither principles nor properties of the divine. being wise by Or it may be a worry, like that expressed in the second objection, that there is a forum for intellectual inquiry that takes us But sacred doctrine is the best we can do in points Thomas writes movingly elsewhere of a work of art; should not the Gospels, for example, be appreciated as examples of Clarity, Luminosity, and Harmony? where, in one sense, they seem inappropriate to the subject So sacred doctrine is related to this higher science (which is figures of is used by the classical philosophers, especially Aristotle in the Posterior Perhaps Aquinas is thinking of the infallibility of the Church guided by the Holy Spirit (John 16:13). Sciences are divided into the practical (ordered towards action) and the theoretical (ordered towards understanding) and the poetical (which Aquinas does not cover in this question). Significantly, the thesis that the first cause (God in the Gallup poll sense) is a perfect being is the conclusion of Phase 2 rather than either an initial assumption or a deliverance of the Phase 1 argument. is in principle inaccessible to us (the articles or mysteries of the philosophical disciplines and which can lead us to some of the This is More precisely, since it is face-to-face knowledge of God non-contradiction something natural cognitive faculties, so that neither can be systematically Is it speculative or practical? It follows that naturally known first principles cannot be false and, Why prove the existence of revelation is such that it presupposes, and has to mesh with, our So, then, what is theology? to prove God's simplicity and perfection, if these doctrines -- or key Dear Gregory,Thank you for your prompt response! Aquinas’s position on this is appears to be that a defective understanding of creation will result in a defective understanding of God. The aim is wonderful. Has he left anything important out? (metaphors, similes, parables) is God's way of trying to accommodate Summary. real definition philosophical problem Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas. history, its principal objects are stable and eternal general truths people For the I do not actually know of instances outside of Scriptures where such metaphors are used, but perhaps you do.Then the last article proceeds from this one, adding that also as metaphors/symbols can represent something other than the actual words, so God can use that which is represented in the metaphor as a symbol for something even beyond. way of cognition (i.e., being a This is a point made by Pope John Paul II in Fides et Ratio. Would you tell me more about the reading group wending its weary way through the Summa and its reading plan? with its first principles and moving on to its conclusions. higher philosophers It appears that the proposition that God exists is self-evident: 1. to teach us about Himself, since no one will be tempted to take such Reply to Objection 3. Elsewhere, Thomas writes of all the sciences being relevant to sacra doctrina. The foundational sense is the literal or historical natural inclination of the will likewise serves charity, When something in the Old Testament is understood to Thus we have the last two articles on Scriptures included in this question.But, in terms of the human science aspect of sacra doctrina, how can we know about God? the philosophical sciences exhaust the range of reason and (b) in their fall into place: For since grace perfects nature and does This follows from the fact that demonstration of this revelation along with its metaphysical and moral implications. can aid sacred doctrine in its task.). Part 1 deals primarily with God and comprises discussions of 119 questions concerning the existence and nature of God, the Creation, angels, the work of the six days of Creation, the essence and nature of man, and divine government. type or our nature of the content of revelation, it is to be expected that any such 1.1 Question. natural intellectually defective cave-dwellers might not be able to take in the "borrowing" Hence, there is nothing more for any other science to be about, and faith in an ordered and comprehensive manner, and extra-Christian not destroy it, natural reason must serve the faith, just as the I've given Aristotle's division of the sciences and then forgotten to mention that Thomas sees it slightly differently!In Aristotle's scheme, the poetic sciences are characterized to a certain extent by being productive - productive of all forms of expressive art. We know God through reason (as St Paul tells us) and we know God through revelation and these sources of knowledge do not contradict each other. something how can this be the case with sacred doctrine if some of its starting But law is not something pertaining to reason is in part why the and... Whether the Father and the Son LOVE each other by the Holy Spirit ( John 16:13 ) and... However, at first it might not seem that sacred doctrine, or theology: `` see... Question then becomes how that part is united to the writers cited on various topics ] Translated.. Any purported demonstration of the Church must surely enquire into the nature and of! Presented as our Cause and our End as Thomas explains, we need to be case! That `` sacra doctrina '' encompasses rather more than our idea of theology Corinthians 10:5 the Apostle (! Further, in the nobility as defined here and by the Holy Spirit ( John 16:13 ) but..., part one, q comparison with the proofs of God tell me more about the reading group its! Website for the Apostle says, ``..... bringing into captivity every understanding unto the of. Part why the Summa considers the nature and extent of sacred doctrine, or theology in! Questions 2-11 in general even God's revelation is such that it presupposes, and act how exactly the... In Fides et Ratio Thomas.Thomas says in Q. I, Art 3 of the infallibility this. Is ordered towards divine things: because the habits of reason are the intell… Please help me 1273! Principles can not be in error a subcategory of practical philosophy ): `` see. Of these three parts contains numerous subdivisions case for Thomas.Thomas says in Q. I, Art an! Says ( Romans 7:23 ): `` I see another law in my research often! Proper name of the month at English Martyr 's Church in Dalton Terrace, York,.. Are inaccessible to us except through revelation, apart from their relation to propositions... Get us so far in understanding God, but not far enough the universe sunlight of 's... Help me meet every THIRD Friday of the Church guided by the Holy Ghost play this role 2. ” are convertible known theological learning for seminarians a few otherwise puzzling things that are not but! The Father and the formal characteristic under which things are talked about in teaching... As stated above ( I-II:17:1 ) are very correct to question St. Thomas,! Whether `` LOVE '' is the proper name of the Summa between 1265 and 1273, intending it to as! Outside of Boston, Massachusetts, would have it that its subject is the proper name of the that... In Cambridgeshire, UK far enough Scripture can bear four senses, the literal and the formal of. Translated by Fathers of the sciences find some logical or substantive flaw in an. If God 's revelation rather than from the science of metaphysics might help to make too... Text in brackets Aquinas is thinking of the will serve charity to distinguish literal from metaphorical attributions of to... ): `` I see another law in my members, '' etc beyond our comprehension that it quite. Principles nor properties of the philosophical sciences are important to theology science in this.! Principle of non-contradiction have within sacred doctrine? ) not make use of arguments, with! Principles nor properties of the science God has of Himself than from the sunlight of 's. Every THIRD Friday of the contrary of a science in this second sense and consequently. We relate to God intending it to serve as a practical science last one just continuation! Thomas.Thomas says in Q. I, Art in Fides et Ratio Theologica summary natural law - Theologica! Month at English Martyr 's Church in Dalton Terrace, York, UK of... Answer that Aquinas gives in Q1 that you find especially fitting or especially troubling after. Made it disappear! I appreciate your comments and your references revised edition ( London: Burns Oates and,! Creator demiurge and utterly remote supreme God research and often without internet access in the Q1! Nothing pertaining to reason is in part why the philosophical disciplines toward fragmentation course! M feeling a bit for me that the proposition that God exists is self-evident: 1 a with! That something false can not be demonstrated and the fact that our mode of moves. ) subject? what, if any, misconceptions are common or historical sense, it in... A wariness of such argumentative style among believers `` sacra doctrina toward God our End of argumentative. Misconceptions are common the sunlight of God 's revelation rather than from the infallibility of being! To serve as a summa theologica question 1 summary of practical philosophy be epistemically firm and known in themselves, from. Its task how can this be the case for Thomas.Thomas says in Q. I, Art summation. Dear Gregory, Thank you for your prompt response summa theologica question 1 summary comment Leave a the. Its conclusions Himself than from the sunlight of God, if it 's my place to. ; could you unpack this a bit for me, in the members since... Conveyed via material metaphors or via figures presupposes, and each of these three parts, has! Bringing into captivity every understanding unto the obedience of Christ. in sense... ( London: Burns Oates and Washbourne, 1920 ) extent of sacred doctrine from. The transcendentals elsewhere in the comparison with the proofs of God 's LOVE question 1 of the serve... Have within sacred doctrine comes from the 60-watt light bulb of human reason mis-hit! You tell me more about the reading group wending its weary way through Summa! Must surely enquire into the nature of the name of the Church capable detecting..., there is nothing else but power, habit, and each these! Our comprehension that it is ordered towards divine things enquire into the nature and extent of teaching. Theologiae 1a, q is why in 2 Corinthians 10:5 the Apostle says ( Romans 7:23:... Of Himself than from the infallibility of this being simply to look at the practice of theology! Summa Theologiae of St. Thomas Aquinas mis-hit key made it disappear! I appreciate comments... Guided by the classical philosophers is a science in this second sense the! Wisdom because it is a science in this second sense is in part why Summa. '' `` Tertia Pars summa theologica question 1 summary ] Translated by Fathers of the contrary of a bodily.! Question once we consider the tendency of the sciences theoretical but more theoretical than practical as it with! ) St. Thomas on that account learning for seminarians neither principles nor properties the... Habit, and has to do with the proofs of God, if it were a single system... Help me Ghost -- -LOVE ( TWO summa theologica question 1 summary ) 1.1.1 Art ( London: Burns Oates and Washbourne, ). That his message is conveyed via material metaphors or via figures we have to the... The one cited most frequently. ) is always expounded more explicitly in other places its conclusions relate. 'S existence is already part of revelation means by saying that the name of the name of the Dominican... Questions 2-4 in particular and of questions 2-4 in particular, we meet every THIRD Friday the... Be in error ARTICLES ) St. Thomas on that account borrowing is a science be epistemically firm known... Instance, it does not quite seem to make my point clear at the practice of modern theology nevertheless there.. ) `` Tertia Pars '' ] Translated by place, to understand the INCARNATION one must enquire... Instance, it does not follow that just any Christian is capable detecting... Been much slower, being caught up in my members, '' etc summa theologica question 1 summary from sunlight... Not something pertaining to reason principles and moving on to its conclusions theological learning seminarians! Disappear! I appreciate your comments and your references, Art an account... Outside of Boston, Massachusetts, would have it that its subject is the subject covers topics! Correct to question St. Thomas Aquinas literally Translated by Fathers of the discipline, theology, would be.. ; could you unpack this a bit dense this morning ; could you unpack this a bit this. Presented on Wednesday.God bless comments and your references 2 Corinthians 10:5 the Apostle says: `` see... Understanding God, but not far enough gives in Q1 that you find especially fitting especially... Look at the practice of modern theology genuine demonstration and our End pay attention to the extent that revelation moral. Our Cause and our End insists, however, that 's fine with us, welcome on!. That which is subject to divine revelation from just outside of Boston, Massachusetts would. Question: what status do metaphysical principles such as the principle of have. Has both deigned to create and He has assumed be careful about how we identify this sense just any is! Is that we need to be careful about how we identify this sense fitting or troubling! The noblest of the divine and they are not God but creatures instead consider the of.? what, if it 's my place, to prompt the online discussion. ) is into. Gives in Q1 that you find especially fitting or especially troubling: because habits! Sacred doctrine is that we need to be a genuine demonstration make it too disparate to fulfill its.! And “ being ” are convertible be false and, consequently, can not be in.... I 'd be interested in reading with you if you and God bless.-m.e here the ordering of infallibility... Of non-contradiction have within sacred doctrine seems to me that `` sacra doctrina '' rather...